100 services are under service tax net with applicable rate of duty of 12.36% and number of taxpayers 4.75 lakh; budget estimates from service tax are Rs.50,200 cr
The Finance Ministry has booked 2181 cases of evasion of service tax in nine months of current fiscal, involving an amount of Rs3491 crore. He urged India Inc. to no longer avoid service tax payment to escape legal and punitive actions.
P C Jha, member, CBEC at a seminar on service tax organized by Assocham confirmed that out of Rs3491 crore of service tax evasion until December 2007, the Finance Ministry had recovered Rs386 crore. During 2006-07, the Ministry detected 4034 cases of evasion, involving an amount of Rs1995 crore out of which Rs554 crore was paid by those who evaded service tax on one pretext or other.
He predicted that by end of fiscal 2007-08, revenue from service tax would have grown by 122 times, the way the government is receiving revenue collections. The contribution of service tax in the total revenue still continues to be small with service sector contribution to GDP increasing from 40% in 1994 to about 55% at present.
The current rate of growth of service sector is about 10% but the contribution of service tax in the total indirect tax collection is only about 18% and its contribution in total tax revenue of the central government is only about 8.6%.
“During the year 2006-07, the total collection from indirect tax was Rs2,40,877 crore out of which collection from service tax was Rs37,483 crore. Remaining amount was Rs1,17,000 crore from excise and about Rs86,000 crore from customs.
In 2007-08, expected revenue from indirect taxes, i.e. customs, excise and service tax collectively was about Rs2,80,000 crore out of which service tax would account for Rs50,200 crore. The collection of service tax during this year is satisfactory and growth so far about 355 which is 1% more than required to achieve the target.
Currently, 100 services are under service tax net with applicable rate of duty of 12.36% and number of such taxpayer have reached 4.75 lakh and the budget estimates from this tax for this year is Rs.50,200 crore. He also informed that the six exclusive service tax Commissionerates at Mumbai, Delhi, Kolkata, Chennai, Bangalore and Ahmedabad have their individual interactive websites. These websites provide assistance to taxpayers in finding out status of their applications and refund claims and in knowing about the procedural or technical requirements.
Revenue department has also set up large taxpayers unit which is a significant measure in the sense that the taxpayers have to remain in touch with one office for the three taxes, i.e. excise, service tax and income tax. In one office also, for all his difficulties, the taxpayer has to contact one officer only, i.e. his own client executive. The first such LTU started functioning at Bangalore w.e.f. October 2006 and the second one has become operational w.e.f 1st December 2007 at Chennai. In future, LTUs would be opened at Dehi, Mumbai and Kolkata also.
During 2006-07, the department made sincere efforts to consolidate circulars/instructions/clarifications issued on various technical and procedural issues. The department has withdrawn 48 circulars and further, two masters circulars have been issued in place of 55 circulars/instructions of the past with the result, now there are only two circulars in place of 103 earlier.
Monday, February 25, 2008
EAC wants indirect taxes adjusted on consumer goods
Economic Advisory Council also asks Finance Minister to increase public investment, change income tax slab to stimulate the economy
Expecting the economy to grow at around 8.5% during next fiscal, the PM’s Economic Advisory Council suggested to Finance Minister P Chidambaram on 16 January to adjust indirect taxes on consumers goods in the budget 2008-09 to give a push to manufacturing sector.
The council also advised the Finance Minister to increase public investment and make adjustments in income tax slab to stimulate the economy.
“Our own view is the economy will grow at 8.5% next year. But, there are some areas of concern where there are weaknesses. They are known like manufacturing,” Council Chairman C Rangarajan told reporters after a Pre-Budget with Finance Minister here.
However, the council did not give suggestion on any major reduction in the tax rates.
Expecting the economy to grow at around 8.5% during next fiscal, the PM’s Economic Advisory Council suggested to Finance Minister P Chidambaram on 16 January to adjust indirect taxes on consumers goods in the budget 2008-09 to give a push to manufacturing sector.
The council also advised the Finance Minister to increase public investment and make adjustments in income tax slab to stimulate the economy.
“Our own view is the economy will grow at 8.5% next year. But, there are some areas of concern where there are weaknesses. They are known like manufacturing,” Council Chairman C Rangarajan told reporters after a Pre-Budget with Finance Minister here.
However, the council did not give suggestion on any major reduction in the tax rates.
Hike fuel prices 20%, LPG Rs50
International crude oil prices are going to stiffen and its in the interest of oil marketing companies that the government effect at least 20% hike in petroleum products
At a time when under recoveries to all marketing companies for petrol, diesel, kerosene and LPG have respectively reached levels of Rs9.20, Rs10.94, Rs19.89 per litre and Rs331.34 per cylinder on LPG, industry chamber Assocham has suggested that the government should at once increase their prices and pass on the burden of increasing under recoveries to the common man and save oil companies from getting bankrupt.
International crude oil prices will further stiffen and are unlikely to be relaxed in view of increasing energy demand and it is in the interest of oil marketing companies that the government effect at least 20% hike in petroleum products like petrol, diesel and kerosene.
In Delhi alone, tax element on petrol works out to the extent of 50% and on diesel, slightly less than 30%; estimates reveal that in 2007, crude oil price at international level increased by over 60% and prices of diesel and petrol by about 58% and 55% respectively. Despite that, their retail prices were kept almost absolutely untouched.
Between March 2002 to December 2007, LPG and kerosene prices internationally become dearer by about 350% and 340% respectively whereas the kerosene retail price was barely increased though LPG prices went up by approximately 16% during the period.
It is also estimated that in 2006-07, there was an average inflation of 5.27% and petrol contribution was around 0.12% and that of diesel 0.38%. Food grains and cereals contributed 0.49%, milk 0.26%, electricity 0.23% in average inflation of 5.27% in 2006-07.
Key Recommendations
* Hike recommended for LPG to be within the range of Rs50 per cylinder
* Subsidy content on petroleum products to be eliminated, otherwise losses of oil marketing companies will exceed much beyond the estimated amount of Rs70,000 crore for current fiscal
* Oil to remain single largest fuel for many decades and continuing subsidies on petrol, diesel and kerosene as also LPG to work against national interests
* FM to increase prices of petroleum products immediately and to rationalize excise element on petrol, diesel, kerosene and LPG as also taxes on transportation of fuels to be made rational
* Government to no longer keep petroleum prices at artificial levels as it would increase consumption of petroleum products and reduce energy conservation and efficiency efforts for which various state sponsored campaigns are going on quite aggressively
At a time when under recoveries to all marketing companies for petrol, diesel, kerosene and LPG have respectively reached levels of Rs9.20, Rs10.94, Rs19.89 per litre and Rs331.34 per cylinder on LPG, industry chamber Assocham has suggested that the government should at once increase their prices and pass on the burden of increasing under recoveries to the common man and save oil companies from getting bankrupt.
International crude oil prices will further stiffen and are unlikely to be relaxed in view of increasing energy demand and it is in the interest of oil marketing companies that the government effect at least 20% hike in petroleum products like petrol, diesel and kerosene.
In Delhi alone, tax element on petrol works out to the extent of 50% and on diesel, slightly less than 30%; estimates reveal that in 2007, crude oil price at international level increased by over 60% and prices of diesel and petrol by about 58% and 55% respectively. Despite that, their retail prices were kept almost absolutely untouched.
Between March 2002 to December 2007, LPG and kerosene prices internationally become dearer by about 350% and 340% respectively whereas the kerosene retail price was barely increased though LPG prices went up by approximately 16% during the period.
It is also estimated that in 2006-07, there was an average inflation of 5.27% and petrol contribution was around 0.12% and that of diesel 0.38%. Food grains and cereals contributed 0.49%, milk 0.26%, electricity 0.23% in average inflation of 5.27% in 2006-07.
Key Recommendations
* Hike recommended for LPG to be within the range of Rs50 per cylinder
* Subsidy content on petroleum products to be eliminated, otherwise losses of oil marketing companies will exceed much beyond the estimated amount of Rs70,000 crore for current fiscal
* Oil to remain single largest fuel for many decades and continuing subsidies on petrol, diesel and kerosene as also LPG to work against national interests
* FM to increase prices of petroleum products immediately and to rationalize excise element on petrol, diesel, kerosene and LPG as also taxes on transportation of fuels to be made rational
* Government to no longer keep petroleum prices at artificial levels as it would increase consumption of petroleum products and reduce energy conservation and efficiency efforts for which various state sponsored campaigns are going on quite aggressively
Friday, February 22, 2008
Citizens want an empowering Budget from FM
A phenomenal increase in the net tax collection can be attributed to strong economic growth, better tax administration and relatively improved compliance levels
As the countdown to the Union Budget 2008 begins, India, whether through corporates, individuals, policymakers or even the stock markets, voices its expectations and dilemmas on the coming event. We take a sneak peek.
The confidence of the Indian public is clearly reflected in figurative terms as the economy grew faster in 2006-07 than previous estimates and clocked 9.6% growth. According to the Central Statistical Organisation estimates, the economy is on course to grow by 8.6% in 2007- 08. The government, in its bid to sustain the high growth, is looking at policy adjustments to capture the mood of the nation. This is especially in view of recent global uncertainties and developments.
For the first time, direct tax collections have surpassed indirect tax collections which are in line with the developed economies across the globe. Recent government data on tax collections paint a happy picture of the economy and the tax collection machinery as far as direct taxes are concerned. During the first nine months of the current fiscal, personal income-tax collections rose by 50% and corporate tax revenues by 39.84% compared with the same period last year.
Such a phenomenal increase in the net tax collection could be attributed to strong economic growth, better tax administration and relatively improved compliance levels. Riding on robust economic growth and extremely positive business sentiment, the buoyant and largely bullish stock market, has also contributed significantly to the excellent growth in tax collections, with collection of securities transaction tax (STT) growing by a sharp 57.61% in the current fiscal.
To top it, increased investor interest in equities induced by strong economic fundamentals, robust flows from foreign institutional investors and an attractive short-term capital gains tax rate have also contributed to the increased tax collections.
People are investing like never before and the per capita income has increased manifold. The government must be keen to capitalize on this investment boom and strike a balance between inflation and growth.
With such positive signs on the tax compliance and collections front, the common man is definitely looking at return gifts from the finance minister. To find out more about what the people of India think, Mint recently ran a survey across a cross-section of individuals in various parts of the country on their expectations from Budget 2008.
Insurance firms line up to cover poor families
The government is willing to pay an insurer up to Rs750 a year to buy an annual health cover worth Rs30,000 for a family of five that lives below poverty line
Is there a fortune at the bottom of the pyramid in health insurance in India? Aggressive bidding by insurers, both private and state-owned, for government contracts to provide health cover to people below the poverty line seems to suggest so.
State governments, which will implement the project, have received bids well below the price they are willing to pay as insurers scramble to get a slice of the expanding market, say executives from the general insurance industry and government officials associated with the project.
The government is willing to pay an insurer up to Rs750 a year to buy an annual health cover worth Rs30,000 for a family of five that lives below poverty line.
Delhi has already awarded the annual contract to state-owned the Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd, said an official from the Union government who did not want to be identified. Information on the value of the winning bid was not available, but a senior company executive confirmed the firm’s successful bid was less than Rs750. Details of the number of people covered under this scheme in Delhi were not immediately available.
The aggressive bids are based on the expectation that premia collected would be large on account of a huge number of people who need health cover, allowing insurers an opportunity to generate significant investment income, said a senior executive in the finance department of a state-owned insurer who did not want to be identified.
“Even if it’s a loss (health cover for a state), it’s worth it,” he said, referring to the advantage provided by annual bids, wherein the company has the option of making an exit at the end of the year.
The entire project, which is scheduled to be rolled out across India by April, plans to provide cover to about 50 million families below the poverty line. The insurers have been asked to follow market determined pricing as the Union and state governments will jointly subsidize the premium.
The Union government had worked out the annual premium at Rs750, of which it would pay 75% and the state governments 25%. Policy holders would be asked to pay Rs30 a year. “People will know (if they pay a nominal amount) that they are covered,” said a senior Union government official familiar with the project who did not wish to be identified.
Some experts saw a larger design to gain market share in the aggressive bids. “I would personally consider the rate offered by the government to be just adequate,” said K.N. Bhandari, secretary-general of General Insurance Council, an industry body. Bhandari, who headed India’s largest general insurer, state-owned New India Assurance, in 2001-02, said the government designated premium was based on rigorous calculation of the data provided by the insurers.
“It’s (the aggressive bidding is) to get a foothold, a strategy to gain market share. It necessarily has to be so in the absence of adequate claims data in health insurance,” said Samir Bali, director, global financial services, Ernst and Young, an audit and consulting firm. Pricing of insurance policies depends on a variety of factors, including previous data on health insurance claims, which isn’t available in India because of low coverage.
The aggressive bids could also be explained by the fact that low bids could impact a firm for just one year, and by the government’s plan to cover the entire below-the-poverty-line population of 250 million over five years, instead of at one go—giving companies an opportunity to recalibrate their bids for subsequent years.
Cosmetics, apparel and mobiles erode family budget: Assocham
Teenagers are spending more on branded products; quality is important to men and women; cosmetic spend by men has increased though for mobile phones they outspend women
About 58% of India’s youth, upper and middle class and over 65% teenagers’ expenses on cosmetics, apparel and mobile phones exceed Rs 2500 per month against their average expenditure of less than Rs 1000 a year in the year 2000 This was attributed largely to an increasing number of women joining employment. With greater awareness, thanks to publicity campaigns that manufacturers mounted, this is likely to grow further.
Findings
*65% teenagers confirmed that their consumption of branded cosmetics had gone up by 30% in the last seven years
*58% youth said their expenses on cosmetic application had risen by 25% as against 57% amongst upper middle age group, claiming they spend nearly 22% in buying cosmetics to maintain their exterior self
*On an average majority felt they were spending by far lesser (around Rs1000)on cosmetics during the year 2000. This had gone up to Rs2500 per month in 2007. This increase was attributed to women’s earning power going up and their increasing aspiration to look younger
*Flooding of print and electronic messages/ endorsements/ advertisements influenced customers in this segment
*Men have developed a special craze for cosmetics and their monthly expense have risen by about 18-20% during the period. They are spending Rs300-500 a month on hair care, deodorants, razors and blades.
*75% male consumers frequently changed their mobile handset twice or thrice a month, pushing their expenditure on mobile phones at much higher levels than females
*About 68% spend Rs150-300 on cosmetics, Rs400-700 on apparel, Rs 600-7000 for mobile on yearly. Rest of the respondents spent in the range of Rs301-500, Rs250-500 & Rs1500-4000 respectively
*Quarter each of housewives and executives spent more than Rs1500-2000 per month on cosmetics and apparel; 32% were students who spent Rs700-1000 per month; 35% were teachers; 25% were businessmen, 23% were govt. employees who spent Rs2000-3000.
* Preference for quality was linked with earning power.
Reflection of trends and attitudes
“Rising hygiene and beauty consciousness due to changing demographics and lifestyles, deeper consumer pockets, higher media exposure, greater product choice, growth in retail segment and wider availability of products were reasons for sharp rising demand of cosmetics, apparel and mobile telephony amongst Indian consumers” summed up Venugopal Dhoot, President, Assocham.
68% respondents in the 15-19 year age group and 73% respondents in the 20-25 year age group felt that “Everybody around them had a mobile”. In the 25-29 years age category, be it a salaried or businessmen, a mobile phone is a “work pre-requisite”.
60% respondents reported that the primary usage of mobile is to keep in touch with friends and to call up their residence whenever they are out. The proportion of business calls is relatively low at 24%. Gender-wise analysis shows that the tendency to call home is more in females than in males, while the habit of calling friends is more common amongst men, essentially teenagers in the age group 15-19 years.
Gender analysis revealed that the awareness level was much higher in boys than in girls. They kept track of market trends and were much more clued up than the girls.
About 58% of India’s youth, upper and middle class and over 65% teenagers’ expenses on cosmetics, apparel and mobile phones exceed Rs 2500 per month against their average expenditure of less than Rs 1000 a year in the year 2000 This was attributed largely to an increasing number of women joining employment. With greater awareness, thanks to publicity campaigns that manufacturers mounted, this is likely to grow further.
In a countrywide survey undertaken by Assocham over 5000 users of cosmetics, apparel and mobile phones were interviewed. Men and women exhibited different choices and spending patterns
Findings
*65% teenagers confirmed that their consumption of branded cosmetics had gone up by 30% in the last seven years
*58% youth said their expenses on cosmetic application had risen by 25% as against 57% amongst upper middle age group, claiming they spend nearly 22% in buying cosmetics to maintain their exterior self
*On an average majority felt they were spending by far lesser (around Rs1000)on cosmetics during the year 2000. This had gone up to Rs2500 per month in 2007. This increase was attributed to women’s earning power going up and their increasing aspiration to look younger
*Flooding of print and electronic messages/ endorsements/ advertisements influenced customers in this segment
*Men have developed a special craze for cosmetics and their monthly expense have risen by about 18-20% during the period. They are spending Rs300-500 a month on hair care, deodorants, razors and blades.
*75% male consumers frequently changed their mobile handset twice or thrice a month, pushing their expenditure on mobile phones at much higher levels than females
*About 68% spend Rs150-300 on cosmetics, Rs400-700 on apparel, Rs 600-7000 for mobile on yearly. Rest of the respondents spent in the range of Rs301-500, Rs250-500 & Rs1500-4000 respectively
*Quarter each of housewives and executives spent more than Rs1500-2000 per month on cosmetics and apparel; 32% were students who spent Rs700-1000 per month; 35% were teachers; 25% were businessmen, 23% were govt. employees who spent Rs2000-3000.
* Preference for quality was linked with earning power.
Reflection of trends and attitudes
“Rising hygiene and beauty consciousness due to changing demographics and lifestyles, deeper consumer pockets, higher media exposure, greater product choice, growth in retail segment and wider availability of products were reasons for sharp rising demand of cosmetics, apparel and mobile telephony amongst Indian consumers” summed up Venugopal Dhoot, President, Assocham.
68% respondents in the 15-19 year age group and 73% respondents in the 20-25 year age group felt that “Everybody around them had a mobile”. In the 25-29 years age category, be it a salaried or businessmen, a mobile phone is a “work pre-requisite”.
60% respondents reported that the primary usage of mobile is to keep in touch with friends and to call up their residence whenever they are out. The proportion of business calls is relatively low at 24%. Gender-wise analysis shows that the tendency to call home is more in females than in males, while the habit of calling friends is more common amongst men, essentially teenagers in the age group 15-19 years.
Gender analysis revealed that the awareness level was much higher in boys than in girls. They kept track of market trends and were much more clued up than the girls.
Cut interest rates and excise for SME’s: Assocham
Reduce excise levy for SME’s as most products fall under high excise slabs, ranging from 16% to 24% to less than 12%; help them adopt efficient quality management systems.
Industry chamber Assocham has urged the Finance Minister to relax interest rates not only for India Inc. but more especially for SME’s as a stronger rupee has already shrunk their margins and it is becoming more difficult for them to ensure their survival.
* Majority of SME’s payments are delayed because faulty deferred payment clause exceeds beyond six months.
* SME’s face severe liquidity crunch as banks and financial institutions insist on collateral and bank guarantee from them as a result of which interests cost to most SME’s go beyond 15% -16%, resultantly effective cost of interest to small and medium entrepreneur works out to be around 18%.
* As a result of resource crunch, and high cost of money with rising rupee appreciation, SME’s have not been able to effect capacity expansion to enhance their production levels and are gradually becoming ineffective to compete at times when modernization and liberalization has reached transition levels.
* SME’s, particularly, tiny and small scale entrepreneurs and their units are more often then not confronted with an increasing menace of inspectors, whose numbers have gone beyond 40; these inspectors create procedural hassles for most SME’s which take up a lot of their time and energies; central government should curtail number of inspectors for SSI.
* Another hurdle faced by SME’s is low levels of research and development (R&D), limited access to technology and product innovations; investing in R&D to innovate by SME’s and government ahead of markets is necessary and should be encouraged; government should review existing policies relating to R&D funding, provide incentives for supporting generic technologies, engineering and physical sciences and take steps to encourage better coordination of efforts with greater focus on innovations and productivity enhancing technologies.
* Create a platform for developing competitiveness in SME’s to extend skill upgradation to SSI through advanced technology; proposed front should enhance SSI manufacturing output and give them skills for safety measures.
* SME’s faced difficulties in adopting expensive quality management systems or certification procedures that sometimes have to be repeated several times; the fund should provide solutions to this effect.
* Lack of information, capability to build up an international market position and maintaining international business relations and insufficient management skills block the growth of SMEs; most enterprises in this sector are more product and technology oriented rather than market oriented; moreover lack of managers with international experience and foreign language skills is another hindrance in their growth.
Industry chamber Assocham has urged the Finance Minister to relax interest rates not only for India Inc. but more especially for SME’s as a stronger rupee has already shrunk their margins and it is becoming more difficult for them to ensure their survival.
The chamber has sought excise reduction in excise levy for SME’s as most of their products fall under high excise slabs, ranging from 16% to 24% to a level of less than 12%.
Pre-budget Recommendations
* Majority of SME’s payments are delayed because faulty deferred payment clause exceeds beyond six months.
* SME’s face severe liquidity crunch as banks and financial institutions insist on collateral and bank guarantee from them as a result of which interests cost to most SME’s go beyond 15% -16%, resultantly effective cost of interest to small and medium entrepreneur works out to be around 18%.
* As a result of resource crunch, and high cost of money with rising rupee appreciation, SME’s have not been able to effect capacity expansion to enhance their production levels and are gradually becoming ineffective to compete at times when modernization and liberalization has reached transition levels.
* SME’s, particularly, tiny and small scale entrepreneurs and their units are more often then not confronted with an increasing menace of inspectors, whose numbers have gone beyond 40; these inspectors create procedural hassles for most SME’s which take up a lot of their time and energies; central government should curtail number of inspectors for SSI.
* Another hurdle faced by SME’s is low levels of research and development (R&D), limited access to technology and product innovations; investing in R&D to innovate by SME’s and government ahead of markets is necessary and should be encouraged; government should review existing policies relating to R&D funding, provide incentives for supporting generic technologies, engineering and physical sciences and take steps to encourage better coordination of efforts with greater focus on innovations and productivity enhancing technologies.
* Create a platform for developing competitiveness in SME’s to extend skill upgradation to SSI through advanced technology; proposed front should enhance SSI manufacturing output and give them skills for safety measures.
* SME’s faced difficulties in adopting expensive quality management systems or certification procedures that sometimes have to be repeated several times; the fund should provide solutions to this effect.
* Lack of information, capability to build up an international market position and maintaining international business relations and insufficient management skills block the growth of SMEs; most enterprises in this sector are more product and technology oriented rather than market oriented; moreover lack of managers with international experience and foreign language skills is another hindrance in their growth.
Govt to ensure 4% farm growth: Chidambaram
Hints at setting up tech fund for agriculture, is confident targeted growth rate will be achieved and sustained through human intervention, technology.
A day after the Central Statistical Organisation projected sluggish agricultural growth for the current fiscal, Finance Minister P Chidambaram said on 8 February the government will take all steps to ensure 4% expansion in the farm sector for next 10-20 years.
A day after the Central Statistical Organisation projected sluggish agricultural growth for the current fiscal, Finance Minister P Chidambaram said on 8 February the government will take all steps to ensure 4% expansion in the farm sector for next 10-20 years.
“The first charge on our resources is for agriculture, so that it grows at 4% or more for next 10-20 years” Chidambaram said at a Nabard function here.
“Everything can wait except agriculture,” he said, adding that the government was committed to take all measures for growth of the farm sector, and was ready to set up a technology fund for it.
The Finance Minister was confident that despite external factor agriculture was capable of achieving and sustaining the stated growth rate through human intervention and technology.
Referring to CSO’s advance estimates of GDP for the current year, he said, “We are confident that agricultural growth would be higher than the advance estimates”.
CSO has estimated that agriculture output would grow at 2.6% this year, against 3.8% last year.
The Finance Minister said, “The Agriculture Ministry has reported yesterday that maize and soyabean production would be all time high this year, that is not reflected in advance estimates.”
Hero Honda wants sops for 2-wheeler industry
Asks govt to streamline corporate tax rate for the sector, lower interest rates, ensure easy availability of finance in rural to boost sagging industry.
With the two-wheeler industry going through one of the worst phase in the recent past, country’s largest bike maker Hero Honda Motors on 7 February asked the government to streamline the corporate tax rate for the sector ahead of the budget.
The company also said the government needed to consider lowering interest rates and ensure easy availability of finance in rural areas for the sector.
“The two-wheeler industry is one of the very few to have seen a degrowth during the last fiscal owed to lack of finance availability in rural areas and extremely high interest rates. We hope the finance minister would look into these things to help the industry get over the slump in sales,” Hero Honda managing director, Pawan Munjal, told PTI on the sidelines of Hero Mindmine Summit.
With the two-wheeler industry going through one of the worst phase in the recent past, country’s largest bike maker Hero Honda Motors on 7 February asked the government to streamline the corporate tax rate for the sector ahead of the budget.
The company also said the government needed to consider lowering interest rates and ensure easy availability of finance in rural areas for the sector.
“The two-wheeler industry is one of the very few to have seen a degrowth during the last fiscal owed to lack of finance availability in rural areas and extremely high interest rates. We hope the finance minister would look into these things to help the industry get over the slump in sales,” Hero Honda managing director, Pawan Munjal, told PTI on the sidelines of Hero Mindmine Summit.
He said the government must also re-look at the corporate tax so as to give some relief to the two wheeler makers.
The two-wheeler industry depends heavily on vehicle financing with a majority of sales, nearly 70%, coming through this route. Owed to high interest rates, a vast majority of two-wheeler buyers had delayed their decision to purchase, leading to an overall decline in sales.
High interest rate regime also forced banks to withdraw financing schemes from various rural markets which add significant volumes to overall two-wheeler sales in the country.
The industry, which grew at a steady pace during a major part of previous fiscal, has seen a dip of nearly 80% in sales during the April-December period of this fiscal.
Tuesday, February 19, 2008
I’d end the unjustified fringe benefit tax
FBT: this is an unfair tax, creates unnecessary opportunities for corruption at lower levels, and really must go
An extension of the STPI (Software Technology Parks of India) scheme, which helped create the software industry in India and which would put the vast majority of IT/ITeS (information technology and information technology-enabled services) companies…, which are SMEs (small and medium enterprises), at par with the big players who have been given the benefit of SEZs (special economic zones).
There are three proposals that have come up in every budget and are shot down but shouldn’t be because they would have an extremely positive impact on the economy:
An extension of the STPI (Software Technology Parks of India) scheme, which helped create the software industry in India and which would put the vast majority of IT/ITeS (information technology and information technology-enabled services) companies…, which are SMEs (small and medium enterprises), at par with the big players who have been given the benefit of SEZs (special economic zones).
Incentives for institutions and individuals to invest in early-stage venture capital funds in order to encourage innovation and entrepreneurship in India.
This includes the restoring of unrestricted pass through.
If you could end one thing, what would that be?
It would be the perfidious, retrograde and completely unjustified fringe benefit tax (FBT), which in fact does not tax fringe benefits but expenditure and hurts SMEs the most.
It would be the perfidious, retrograde and completely unjustified fringe benefit tax (FBT), which in fact does not tax fringe benefits but expenditure and hurts SMEs the most.
What would be the one thing outside your industry you would want in the Budget?
Freeing up of higher education to the private sector and educational institutions around the world. Our current “dog in the manger” policy results in the government neither making sufficient investment in this area..., nor allowing private-sector overseas players to do so. The result is that Indian parents spend an estimated $10 billion (Rs39,700 crore) to send their kids abroad for higher studies as they couldn’t get into decent institutions in India.
What is the one thing you don’t want changed?
The belated focus on infrastructure and primary education.
Which budget disappointed you the most? Why?
Last year’s budget. The economy was buoyant, tax collections had been unprecedented and so the finance minister had phenomenal room in which to create a visionary, forward-looking budget, but in the end only did some tinkering and introduced totally unnecessary changes that proved disastrous for India’s crown jewel—the knowledge industries as also the venture funds that invest in innovation.
One proposal you think is shot down in every budget but shouldn’t be.
1. Lowering of personal and corporate income-tax rates. The extremely buoyant tax collections are a tribute to what lower income-tax rates can do.
2. FBT: this is an unfair tax, creates unnecessary opportunities for corruption at lower levels, and really must go.
3. The extension of the STPI scheme.
3. The extension of the STPI scheme.
What would you consider to be inclusive growth?
Inclusive growth for me is not stop-gap, one-off measures that dole out some freebies to the weaker sections of society for election purposes, nor is it quotas in IITs (the Indian Institutes of Technology). If we are serious about inclusive growth, the kind of measures we should look at include:
1. Vouchers to children from underprivileged sections for free education in a school of their choice rather than forcing them into government schools.
2. Ensuring the quality of teachers and facilities at government-run primary schools.
3. Vastly enhance the number of scholarships for children from weaker sections to pursue higher studies at premier institutions.
4. Urban-level infrastructure in villages including connectivity by road and rail that would allow livelihoods to be created for the rural poor rather than have them come and over strain the already weak urban infrastructure.
5. Significantly encourage creation of microcredit, leading to creation of micro-enterprises and entrepreneurs among the weaker sections.
Union Budget 2008 | Package to address farmers’ debts soon
Addressing FICCI’s AGM, the PM noted that 80% of the agricultural sector was outside the formal financial system and suffered from excessive indebtedness
The government will soon come out with a package to address the indebtedness of farmers, Prime Minister Manmohan Singh said on Friday, 15 February.
The government will soon come out with a package to address the indebtedness of farmers, Prime Minister Manmohan Singh said on Friday, 15 February.
“We are looking into the credit needs of farmers. We cannot have a situation, where 80% of this sector is outside the formal financial system and suffers from excessive indebtedness. We are trying to resolve this problem. I hope this would be done soon,” he said at industry chamber FICCI’s AGM here.
Pointing out that the share of agriculture in the GDP has been declining, Singh said: “We cannot minimise the importance of this sector, for our economy and our polity.”
Agriculture is important, he said, because it supports a significant portion of the country’s population and also acts as a social safety net.
The government had earlier convened a special meeting of the National Development Council on Agriculture and has announced two agriculture programmes envisaging an expenditure of Rs35,000 crore during the 11th five year plan.
“We are looking at ways of having a quantum jump in investment in irrigation,” the Prime Minister said, adding that the allocation for agriculture and irrigation has been trebled in the 11th plan as compared to the previous plan.
The decision of the government to substantially increase the minimum support price of wheat and rice, he said, “demonstrates our commitment to reversing the unfortunate trend we saw between the mid 1990s and the mid-2000s of decline in investment in agriculture and a shift of the terms of trade away from agriculture.”
These initiatives, he hoped, would push up the agriculture growth rate to 4%in the coming years.
According to CSO estimates, farm sector will grow at a sluggish rate of 2.6%this fiscal against 3.8% last fiscal.
Law set to get tougher on disclosures
The proposed law will try to remove inequalities in penalties for violations of norms by companies
The government is contemplating to strengthen penal provisions and provide for tough disclosure norms in the new Companies Act, which will be introduced in Parliament in the forthcoming Budget session.
The government is contemplating to strengthen penal provisions and provide for tough disclosure norms in the new Companies Act, which will be introduced in Parliament in the forthcoming Budget session.
The proposed law will try to remove inequalities in penalties for violations of norms by companies, officials said, adding it will ensure that all wrongdoings by the companies are dealt with professionally.
It will also be the endeavour of the government to streamline disclosure norms to tighten corporate governance and introduce shareholders’ democracy, they said. In addition, the new law would also provide for time-bound liquidation of companies in case of debt default or winding up.
To enhance shareholders’ democracy, officials said, the government is also thinking of removing the provisions that allow directors to take important decisions on investments and share issuance.
In the proposed company law, the ministry of corporate affairs would introduce some disclosure schemes, they said.
On matters such as investment and issue of share, companies may be required to take prior approval from their shareholders. This is to curtail powers of the board of directors of a company.
It would be a major shift from the present Companies Act, 1956, as this ‘approval regime’ would bring greater transparency in the functioning of the corporates and make them more accountable to their shareholders.
Tax pass-through ought to be restored
The last budget limited the pass-through only to venture capitalist funds focused only on certain sectors like nanotechnology, biotech, hotels and dairy farming
Budget 2008-09 comes up next week and domestic venture capital funds—funds (venture capital and private equity) registered with the Securities and Exchanges Board of India (Sebi)—hope that the tax pass-through benefit earlier available to them will be restored. Till February 2007, domestic venture capital funds (VCF) enjoyed 100% tax exemption on income from exits (sale of investments).
Budget 2008-09 comes up next week and domestic venture capital funds—funds (venture capital and private equity) registered with the Securities and Exchanges Board of India (Sebi)—hope that the tax pass-through benefit earlier available to them will be restored. Till February 2007, domestic venture capital funds (VCF) enjoyed 100% tax exemption on income from exits (sale of investments).
This was amended in the last budget to limit the pass-through only to VCFs focused on certain sectors, notably nanotechnology, biotech, hotels and dairy.
Why finance minister P.Chidambaram deemed only these sectors as “truly deserving” over others continues to baffle most folks in the industry. The Indian Venture Capital Association (Ivca), in a letter to the minister shortly after the budget, pointed out; “The Budget’s notable exclusions are some of the fastest growing and innovation driven areas such as KPO/BPO, telecom, wireless value-added services, media and entertainment and health care…”
Now, it is true that none of the sectors that have been excluded from the pass-through have actually suffered in terms of attracting investors.
In fact, investments in sectors such as wireless value-added services, telecom and KPO have grown quite significantly in the last 12 months. That is so because the majority of investors are foreign funds (not registered with Sebi), which work out of “tax-neutral jurisdictions” such as Mauritius and enjoy exemptions under double tax avoidance agreements. As long as confidence in the Indian economy is strong, and it is likely to remain so for a while, such foreign investors will keep most sectors well funded.
But, consider for a moment the scenario that existed between 2001 and 2004. This was a time when investor interest in India was at an all-time low, driven by factors such as the Internet bust and recession in the US, which alone accounted for 90% of direct venture capital investments in India.
The absence of a local, self-sustaining venture capital industry was sorely felt at the time. Total investments during this period languished at significantly less than $1 billion (Rs3,970 crore at current exchange rates). And, while mature businesses still managed to scrape together some investors, early-stage businesses all but perished.
After 2005, the scenario changed and one of the most welcome changes was the growing number of domestic VCFs. These funds are still backed by foreign institutional money, but for all practical purposes operate as local entities. As a result, investments have gone wider and deeper into sectors that earlier did not come under the radar of venture capital.
A big incentive for the emergence of such funds was the tax pass-through. It was assumed that over time, such funds would come to be backed by domestic institutional investors and lead to a truly self-sustaining industry.
The finance minister’s intentions last year were no doubt noble—it is a fact that sectors such as nanotechnology and biotech required an extra push. Venture capitalists are still not rushing in to fund companies in these sectors but it was necessary to bring them into focus.
But, as Ivca puts it, “We need to leave it to entrepreneurs and investors to decide on what are the promising and potential growth areas of the future. No one can predict what these are and that is why no government in the world even attempts to do so.” Let’s hope the finance minister is listening.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)